Most people pick insurance based on price. We show you what happens after you file a claim — based on complaint data from NAIC and state regulators.
Claims Grade
Far fewer complaints than average
Below average complaints
Near industry average
Above average complaints
Far more complaints than average
American Family Insurance Co receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
Auto-Owners Insurance Co receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
Erie Insurance Exchange receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
Indiana Farmers Mutual Insurance Co receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
Safeco Insurance Co Of Indiana receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
United Farm Family Mutual Insurance Co receives far fewer complaints than average. Strong claims track record.
Allstate Property & Casualty Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
American Select Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Farmers New Century Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
GEICO Choice Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
GEICO Secure Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Integon Indemnity Corp receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Progressive Southeastern Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Root Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Shelter Mutual Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Standard Fire Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
State Farm Fire & Casualty Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
The Cincinnati Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
Zurich American Insurance Co receives fewer complaints than the industry average.
American Family Insurance Co SI is close to the industry average for complaints.
Bristol West Insurance Co is close to the industry average for complaints.
Garrison Property & Casualty Insurance Co is close to the industry average for complaints.
Progressive Paloverde Insurance Co is close to the industry average for complaints.
Selective Insurance Co Of America is close to the industry average for complaints.
The Cincinnati Casualty Co is close to the industry average for complaints.
Ace American Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Allstate Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Auto Club Group Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Canal Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Consolidated Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Encompass Indemnity Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Federated Mutual Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
GEICO Advantage Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Imperial Fire & Casualty Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Motorists Commercial Mutual Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
Old Republic Insurance Co receives significantly more complaints than average.
United Services Automobile Association receives significantly more complaints than average.
American Access Casualty Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
American Freedom Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
American Modern Property & Casualty Ins Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Automobile Club Inter-Insurance Exchange receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Charter Oak Fire Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Cherokee Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Clearcover Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Depositors Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Direct General Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Elephant Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Esurance Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Falcon Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Farmers Group Property & Casualty Ins Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Farmers Insurance Exchange receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
First Acceptance Insurance Co Inc receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
First Chicago Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Founders Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
GEICO Indemnity Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Hartford Fire Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Hartford Insurance Co Of The Southeast receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Hudson Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Memberselect Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Mendakota Casualty Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Mennonite Mutual Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
MGA Insurance Co Inc receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Midwest Family Mutual Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
National General Assurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
National Specialty Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Nationwide General Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Ohio Security Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Permanent General Assurance Corp receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Safe Auto Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
State Auto Property & Casualty Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Stillwater Property & Casualty Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Trexis Insurance Corp receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Trumbull Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Trustgard Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
USAA Casualty Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
USAA General Indemnity Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.
Young America Insurance Co receives far more complaints than average. High friction risk.